I tried various overshoes and they all fell apart in one way or another. Until I got a pair of PRO overshoes. They've lasted me 3 winters now and are still in top shape. Sadly I don't think you can buy these any more.
Jaygee's tip about Velotoze is good though. So snug they'll keep the water out. Put them on, then your bib tights or leg warmers, then just bung a pair of overshoes over the top.
I'll +1 the pro overshoes. Rain ones, thinner and waterproof. Seem to do the job pretty well (3 winters too). Ugliest things I've ever put on my feet though.
TBH I wear Defeet oversocks 99% of the in the winter - unless it's pouring or below 0.
Dan
@Sam
I tried various overshoes and they all fell apart in one way or another. Until I got a pair of PRO overshoes. They've lasted me 3 winters now and are still in top shape. Sadly I don't think you can buy these any more.
Jaygee's tip about Velotoze is good though. So snug they'll keep the water out. Put them on, then your bib tights or leg warmers, then just bung a pair of overshoes over the top.